Critic: AI Design Critic Agent
Critic is an AI design critic that gives structured, specific design critique and reviews designs against WCAG accessibility guidelines before they ship.
Last updated:
What does Critic do?
Critic is the Design Critic in the xSquads Design Squad. Critiques designs and reviews accessibility. It works on your own files in the xSquads desktop app, and it drafts rather than sends: anything that leaves your company waits for your approval.
Critic at a glance
- Role
- Design Critic
- Squad
- Design Squad (Design)
- Works with
- System (Design Systems Lead), Insight (UX Researcher), Copy (UX Writer)
- Who approves the work
- You. Drafts wait for your review before anything is sent or published.
- Skills
- 2 skills
- Connections needed
- None beyond the app
Common problems Critic solves
Where this work usually goes wrong, and what Critic does about it.
Feedback that is just taste
The problem: Design reviews turn into 'I don't like it', and designers cannot act on that.
How Critic handles it: Critic gives structured critique with design-critique: what works, what does not and why, tied to the design's goals.
Accessibility checked after launch
The problem: Contrast, focus states and screen reader issues are found by users, not reviewers.
How Critic handles it: Critic reviews designs against WCAG with accessibility-review and lists each issue with a fix.
Review rounds with no end
The problem: Without a clear structure, every review raises new opinions instead of closing old ones.
How Critic handles it: Critic uses the same structure every time, so each round can be checked against the last.
How Critic is tuned for the job
Critic is not a general chatbot with a new name. It runs with a fixed role, a focus list and skills it reads before each task, so its output is consistent and on point from the first request.
What keeps it fast and accurate
- Ties each point to a goal or a guideline, not to personal preference.
- Names the WCAG criterion behind each accessibility issue.
- Ranks issues so the important ones get fixed first.
Its standing focus
- Give structured design critique.
- Review WCAG accessibility.
Skills it reads before a task
- design-critique
- accessibility-review
Rules it always works by
- Asks one short clarifying question only when a task is truly ambiguous; otherwise it states its assumption and gets on with it.
- Drafts, does not send: anything that leaves your company, such as an email, a post, a ticket reply or a contract, waits for you to review and approve.
- Leads with the answer and keeps caveats to one line, with depth only when you ask for it.
- Cites sources and never invents facts, figures, quotes or links; it says what it could not verify.
- Keeps notes on your preferences, voice and standing decisions in memory and reuses them.
- Reads the relevant skill before a task the skill covers, and follows it.
What you can ask Critic to do
Requests are written in plain language. A few examples:
- Critique this checkout flow design
- Review these screens for WCAG accessibility issues
- What would make this landing page easier to scan?
- Check contrast and focus states on the new components
Critic's teammates in the Design Squad
Add Critic on its own, or import the whole squad so each part of the work goes to the agent built for it.
Frequently Asked Questions About Critic, the AI Design Critic
What does Critic need to review a design?
Screenshots, exported frames or a description of the design and its goals. The clearer the goal, the more specific the critique.
Does Critic check accessibility?
Yes. Critic reviews designs against the WCAG accessibility guidelines and lists each issue with the criterion it relates to and a fix.
How do I add Critic to xSquads?
Open the xSquads app, go to Explore agents, find Critic under the Design Squad and choose Add Critic. Critic joins your sidebar as its own chat with its skills ready. To get the whole team, import the Design Squad from Squad templates.
Put Critic to work
Download xSquads, open Explore agents and add Critic. Or have the xSquads team set it up for your team and tune it to how you work.